The Ghost of “Dred Scott vs. Sanford Is Haunting the Supreme Court

Weekly Mourner 1
By screm

The Supreme Court struck down a Louisiana law (re-read that slowly and shudder) requiring abortionists to be members in good standing and able to admit patients, also referred to as “admitting privileges”, the text from the bill defines it as such: 
 "[A]ctive admitting privileges" means "the physician is a member in good standing of the medical staff of a hospital that is currently licensed by the department, with the ability to admit a patient and to provide diagnostic and surgical services to such patient."at hospitals within 30 miles of their clinics, for the safety of women who choose to abort their children. The law, called “The Louisiana Unsafe Abortion Protection Act” passed overwhelmingly in 2014. It never went into effect due to being tied up in court. 

It’s obvious that this was an unconstitutional decision from the high court. Chief Justice Roberts was the deciding vote in the case and a controversial vote he was indeed. He shockingly argued that he decided against Louisiana due to the “binding precedent” of a previous similar decision against Texas that Roberts claims to disagree with. 

Cue the spooky music. Where have we seen this before? What dark and malignant specter does this decision invoke?

What do you know about the infamous “Dred Scott” case?

Was “Dred Scott vs. Sanford” (the 1857 Supreme Court decision that rendered Dred Scott a slave again after having attained his freedom) under “binding precedent” as well? In a very real way, then Chief, Roger Taney, argued then that it WAS in so many words, as the Chief Justice shockingly did for this decision today. 

The horrific, immoral, equivalent here is simply undeniable. 

This is a stunning lack of regard for the plain empirical proof of human life in the womb. That proof should render any precedent void if such precedent stands to allow those human beings to be destroyed. Surely an errant and eisegetic ruling like “Roe” that decided the bloody fate of what is now tens of millions of preborn children should be decried by generations who now know better. Generations who can see better.  “Dred Scott” was decried by the people when it came down. Think about that. An antebellum outcry for Dred Scott. The only people not outraged by it were of course the Democrats in the slave holding states. 

Put simply, “binding precedent” can be a monstrous justification of the inhumane destruction and degrading of human life as it was in “Dred Scott”.  It was so today. 

Fredrick Douglas spoke elegantly of the nightmare decision:
“...my hopes were never brighter than now. I have no fear that the National Conscience will be put to sleep by such an open, glaring, and scandalous tissue of lies...”
“The Constitution knows all the human inhabitants of this country as “the people.” It makes, as I have said before, no discrimination in favor of, or against, any class of the people, but is fitted to protect and preserve the rights of all, without reference to color, size, or any physical peculiarities.”
 
How perfectly relevant are the great man’s words for us here and now and for the little ones whose lives are at stake.




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Food, Food Shortages, and Your Fundamental Independence

Image
Weekly Mourner 7, August 24, 2020 By Ethan Elgersma (contributor) (From the Editor) This article by a guest contributor is about food. Oh yeah. And it is a recipe of sorts. A really good one. It’s a recipe we all need to begin to follow.      My Grandparents canned food for years. It was food that they had grown in their own sizable garden. I remember thinking about it like it was magic when I was little. What I mean by that is that I couldn’t wrap my mind around how someone could grown their own food, turn it into delicious, organic, tomato sauce, for example, and then keep jars and jars of it for what seemed like years. They had a whole pantry full of food they had grown and stored. They grew their own herbs and spices too. It’s not that they didn’t shop at a grocery store, but a great deal of the food we would eat at Sunday dinner was garden grown right in their own backyard. My Grandfather also composted scraps and replenished his own garden beds with it....
Read more

How to Look at Basquiat, Chapter 2: “The Avenging Spirit of Jean Michel Basquiat.”

Image
Weekly Mourner 3, part 2  by  screm, July 2020 “GRILLO”.  Grillo.” 1984.  Acrylic, oil, xerox collage, oilstick, and nails on wood, four panels. 244 x 537.2 x  45.7 cm.   As the mist settled over the small village, in the lateness of the hot time of the year, Bibuwa knew in his pure heart that something had changed in the air. A foul coldness seemed to settle over everything, and a vibration too, like the lightning in the sky just before it struck. Something had been loosed in the sweltering jungle of the Congo and all these sensations were to Bibuwa a sign of the presence of that something. What had begun for Bibuwa as an earnest trade of a few goats for the supplies to furnish a better dwelling for his family, seemed now to take a turn toward the terror of a bad dream.        Kabunji had only reluctantly sealed the agreement for the supplies with Bibuwa, and Bibuwa had to admit to himself that he knew in his heart that Kabunji did not...
Read more

Time For a Boycott

Image
Thoughts on Netflix’s Propogation of Child Sexual Exploitation Weekly Mourner 8 By screm, September 2020 I cancelled my Netflix subscription today. I want to strongly encourage you all to do the same.      Reed Hastings and Netflix went forward with airing a movie called “cuties” about a group of 11 year old girls who run from their families to form what is essentially a burlesque dance group. I can’t see any reason to keep Netflix after this horrific decision. In fact, some people should go to prison for what they did to these girls in this movie; Reed Hastings included. Still, all of the producers, directors, and fundraisers would be a good start. I’d be ok if they never saw the light of day again. A dark, dank, cold cell is where these dark, dank, cold minds should be placed until the day they die. Too harsh? I don’t think so. If you’re the type of corrupted mind that will exploit young girls for sexual, financial, and/or corrupt social causes like the normal...
Read more